6 Best Replacement Baking Trays for Cuisinart Toaster Ovens (November 2026)
The best Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacements include the Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-60 Convection Toaster for exact TOA-60 replacement, the COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart for tray and basket versatility, and the COWHERDING Baking Sheet Pan Set for two baking pans.
On this page (3 sections)
The best Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacement for most TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 owners is the COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement, because it includes a 12.4 x 11 in baking pan and a mesh basket. That mix suits a kitchen that bakes, roasts and air fries with the same oven.
Choose a Cuisinart crumb tray when you need an exact model-specific replacement. A crumb tray does a narrower job, and paying for a basket or extra pan may not help if the lower tray is the only missing part.
A replacement tray only works well when its size and shape match the oven cavity. Check the model number first, then compare the replacement length, width and height with the old tray and the oven rails.
Measure before you order, even when the model name looks familiar. Height matters as much as footprint, because a tray that is too tall can sit badly on the rack or stop the door from closing cleanly.
Think about the jobs you actually do each week. A solid pan helps with baking, reheating and catching drips, while a mesh basket lets air reach food from more sides when you cook fries, wings or vegetables.
Also think about cleaning and storage. A set with two pieces gives you a spare while one part is in the sink, but it also takes more cupboard space than a single tray.
If your oven uses a smaller rectangular tray, compare our guide to best toaster oven tray 8x10 options. That size works differently from the 12.4 x 11 in compact Cuisinart replacements in this guide.
For broader bakeware planning, see our guide to bakeware sets, and use the best dishes for toaster oven guide when you need a baking dish rather than a flat tray. A dish holds food deeper, so it suits casseroles and reheats that a flat pan cannot contain.
Start with your oven label and the part you are replacing. Model fit, dimensions and included pieces will tell you more than a generic promise of compatibility.
Our picks at a glance
-
1
Best for exact TOA-60 replacementCuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-60 Convection Toaster
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for tray and basket versatilityCOWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
- 4
Check itGCQ Air Fryer Baking Tray for Cuisinart
Best for TOA-95 and wide ovens - 5
Check itCuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-70 AirFryer Oven
Best for exact TOA-70 crumb tray - 6
Check itSettleDown Air Fryer Basket Tray Replacement
Best for a 2-piece TOA accessory set
The best Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacements
The best replacement depends on whether you need a crumb tray, baking pan, basket or multi-piece set. Those parts sit in different places and do different jobs inside the oven.
Cuisinart own parts are the most direct model matches, while the stainless steel accessory sets offer more cooking uses. A crumb tray collects debris, a solid pan cooks food directly, and a mesh basket improves airflow for air frying.
Our score weighs model fit, stated dimensions, included parts, material and buyer feedback against the needs of someone shopping for a Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacement. Fit comes first, because a tray that does not slide in properly cannot do any other job well.
The order below follows that logic. Exact Cuisinart parts come first for simple replacements, then wider accessory sets for owners who want baking and air frying in one purchase.
Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-60 Convection Toaster: Best for exact TOA-60 replacement
- Compatible with TOA-60
- Replacement crumb tray
- Metal construction
- 1 count
This Cuisinart replacement crumb tray is the most direct match for a TOA-60 oven. It suits owners who need the original tray type rather than a larger baking pan or air fryer basket.
Pros
- Cuisinart brand
- Made for TOA-60
- Simple one-part replacement
Cons
- Compatible model is TOA-60 only
- Crumb tray rather than baking pan
The Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer is the clearest choice when the missing part is the crumb tray in a TOA-60. It is a Cuisinart part made for that model, with a metal construction and a 1-count package.
This is not a baking sheet or an air fryer basket. Its job is to replace the lower crumb tray, so it makes sense for an owner whose original tray is damaged, missing or difficult to clean.
The model match matters more than adding extra accessories. If you own a TOA-60 and only need the lower tray, a single model-specific part avoids paying for a basket or pan you may not use.
It also suits a second-hand purchase or a spare-parts drawer. Keeping the correct Cuisinart tray on hand means a worn or warped lower tray does not stop the oven from being used for toast and reheating.
Check the oven label before ordering and keep the old tray nearby for comparison. The simple one-part format is a strength only when TOA-60 is the exact model you own.
Choose this part when your oven label says TOA-60. If you want a cooking surface for roasting or baking, compare the COWHERDING sets below instead.
COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart: Best for tray and basket versatility
- 12.4 x 11 in baking pan
- 11.5 x 10 x 2 in basket rack
- Compatible with TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70
- Stainless steel
This 2-piece set covers baking and air frying in one purchase. The 12.4 x 11 in pan and 11.5 x 10 x 2 in basket rack make it a strong choice when you need more than a crumb tray.
Pros
- Pan and mesh basket included
- Fits 3 Cuisinart models
- Dishwasher safe and hand-wash care
Cons
- Not an exact replacement for every Cuisinart tray
- Dimensions still need checking
The COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart gives you a 12.4 x 11 in baking pan and an 11.5 x 10 x 2 in basket rack. It is compatible with Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 models.
The stainless steel set covers two different needs. Use the solid pan for baking or catching drips, and use the mesh basket when air circulation matters for foods such as fries, wings or vegetables.
The basket height also gives food more room than a flat sheet alone. That extra depth helps when you spread chopped vegetables or frozen snacks in a single layer without crowding the pan.
COWHERDING states that the tray and basket are dishwasher safe, with hand washing and thorough drying recommended for longer life. The care guidance also says to avoid rough abrasive cloths and metal balls.
Before first use, follow the maker preheat guidance for the steel parts. Let the tray cool before handling, and soak stuck food rather than scraping it hard.
Before ordering, measure the oven rails and compare them with both stated dimensions. Model names help narrow the choice, but the interior opening still decides whether the replacement slides in properly.
COWHERDING Baking Sheet Pan Set: Best for two baking pans
- 2 stainless steel trays
- 12.4 x 11 x 0.78 in dimensions
- Compatible with TOA-060, TOA-065 and TOA-70
- Nonstick finish
Two matching trays help when you bake in batches or want a spare ready while one is being washed. The stainless steel pans fit the same Cuisinart model group as the air fryer set.
Pros
- 2 trays included
- Stainless steel construction
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- No basket included
- Check the 0.78 in height against your oven
The COWHERDING Baking Sheet Pan Set includes 2 stainless steel trays measuring 12.4 x 11 x 0.78 in each. It is designed for Cuisinart TOA-060, TOA-065 and TOA-70 toaster oven accessories.
This set fits buyers who want a spare pan or who bake in batches. For more flat baking surfaces, compare nonstick cookie sheets.
Two matching trays can reduce interruptions when one pan is cooling or being washed, although the set does not include an air fryer basket.
The trays have a nonstick finish and are dishwasher safe. The stated temperature resistance reaches up to 480°F, and the maker recommends avoiding rough abrasive tools during cleaning.
The 0.78 in height is useful to check before buying. A tray can match the length and width yet still sit too high for the oven rack or interfere with the door.
Use this set when your main need is baking or broiling with two flat pans. For muffins, compare muffin pans for toaster ovens.
Choose the COWHERDING basket-and-tray set instead when air frying is part of the plan.
GCQ Air Fryer Baking Tray for Cuisinart: Best for TOA-95 and wide ovens
- 14.5 x 11.6 x 0.8 in size
- Direct fit for TOA-95
- Works on the original rack in select ovens
- Dishwasher safe
The GCQ tray is the larger option for Cuisinart TOA-95 owners and certain wide toaster ovens. Its 14.5 x 11.6 in footprint needs more interior room than the 12.4 x 11 in trays.
Pros
- Larger cooking surface
- Direct TOA-95 compatibility
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Not intended for the smaller TOA-60 group
- Only 1 pan included
The GCQ Air Fryer Baking Tray is the larger choice, measuring 14.5 x 11.6 x 0.8 in. It is designed for direct use in the Cuisinart TOA-95 and can also work with the Breville BOV900BSS and Black & Decker Extra-Wide 8-Slice oven when placed on the original wire rack.
Its larger surface suits wider ovens and cooking tasks such as cookies, roasted vegetables, reheated fries and sheet-pan meals. The tray is made from steel and is dishwasher safe.
GCQ recommends a one-time preheat at 300°F for about 10 minutes before first use. The stated maximum temperature is 480°F, so use the tray within that limit.
The most important check is the oven interior. At 14.5 x 11.6 in, this tray is not the right starting point for a compact TOA-60 replacement search.
Choose it for a TOA-95 or compatible wide oven. For the smaller TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 group, compare the 12.4 x 11 in options first.
Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-70 AirFryer Oven: Best for exact TOA-70 crumb tray
- Compatible with TOA-70
- Replacement crumb tray
- Cuisinart part
- 1.1 lb item weight
This Cuisinart part is the direct crumb-tray choice for the TOA-70 AirFryer Oven with Grill. It suits owners who want the model-specific part instead of a multi-piece accessory set.
Pros
- Cuisinart brand
- Made for TOA-70
- Direct crumb-tray replacement
Cons
- Compatible model is TOA-70 only
- No baking pan or basket included
The Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-70 AirFryer Oven with Grill is the direct choice for a TOA-70 crumb tray. It is a Cuisinart replacement part, and the product description identifies TOA-70 as its compatible model.
This option is more focused than the multi-piece accessory sets. It does not add a baking pan or basket, so it suits an owner replacing the lower tray rather than expanding the oven cooking setup.
That focus can be a good fit for everyday toast and reheat use. You get the part your oven was designed to use, without extra pieces to wash or store.
The item weight is 1.1 lb, and the package dimensions are 16.5 x 13 x 1.5 in. Those package measurements are not the same as the installed tray size, so use the oven model and the old part for fit checks.
Keep the old tray until the replacement is in place. Comparing shape, lip and seating position is a safer check than relying on package size alone.
Pick this part when your TOA-70 needs its crumb tray replaced. If you need a pan for baking, look at the COWHERDING 2-piece pan set or the larger GCQ tray.
SettleDown Air Fryer Basket Tray Replacement: Best for a 2-piece TOA accessory set
- 12.4 x 10.98 x 1.3 in dimensions
- 2-piece set
- Compatible with TOA-060 and TOA-065
- Stainless steel
This SettleDown set gives TOA-060 and TOA-065 owners both a basket and tray. Its 12.4 x 10.98 x 1.3 in size is close to the other compact Cuisinart replacements, but still deserves a measurement check.
Pros
- Basket and tray included
- Stainless steel
- Dishwasher safe and hand-wash care
Cons
- Compatibility does not name TOA-70
- No exact model-specific Cuisinart branding
The SettleDown Air Fryer Basket Tray Replacement is a 2-piece stainless steel set for Cuisinart TOA-060 and TOA-065 ovens. The basket and tray measure 12.4 x 10.98 x 1.3 in.
Its basket-and-tray format suits owners who want both air-frying airflow and a solid surface for catching drips. SettleDown describes the parts as dishwasher safe, while also giving hand-wash-only care guidance for the replacement parts.
That care wording is worth reading in full before you buy. Dishwasher safe does not always mean the maker expects daily dishwasher use to be the best way to keep the finish looking new.
The stated dimensions are close to the other compact replacements, but the 1.3 in height makes a direct measurement especially useful. Check the oven rails, door clearance and the space above the tray before ordering.
This set is aimed at TOA-060 and TOA-065 owners. If your label shows a different model, treat it as a measurement check rather than a safe assumption.
This set does not name TOA-70 in its compatibility information. For a TOA-70, the COWHERDING set or the Cuisinart model-specific part gives you a clearer starting point.
How to choose a Cuisinart toaster oven replacement tray
Choose by oven model first, tray function second and dimensions third. A crumb tray sits in a different position from a baking pan, so replacing one with the other may not solve the same problem.
Which Cuisinart models do the trays fit?
The Cuisinart parts here are model-specific. The first Cuisinart replacement fits TOA-60, while the second fits TOA-70.
The third-party sets cover different groups. COWHERDING names TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 for the 12.4 x 11 in pan and basket set, while its 2-tray set names TOA-060, TOA-065 and TOA-70.
SettleDown names TOA-060 and TOA-065, and GCQ names TOA-95.
Model numbers with leading zeroes can appear differently across product names. Match the full label printed on your oven and compare the tray measurements before buying.
Should you buy a crumb tray or baking pan?
Buy a crumb tray when you need the lower part that collects food debris. Buy a baking pan when you need a cooking surface for baking, roasting or broiling.
The Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-70 parts are the focused crumb-tray choices. The COWHERDING and SettleDown sets are better for buyers who need a basket and pan for active cooking.
Start by finding the model number on the oven label. That one step removes many replacements that look right in photos but were made for a different cavity.
Next, decide how you cook most often. Frequent toast and reheating may need only a crumb tray, while weekly fries, wings or roasted vegetables benefit from a mesh basket.
Then measure the rails and compare length, width and height. Leave room for the door to close and for the tray to slide in and out without forcing it.
Material is the next filter. Stainless steel sets suit baking and air frying, while a metal crumb tray suits a simple lower-tray replacement.
Care matters after the first cook. Soak stuck bits, use a soft sponge, and dry the tray well when hand washing is advised.
If you need a different style of pan, compare the best toaster oven pan set options. A deeper pan set can suit casseroles and layered reheats that a flat tray cannot hold.
For cookies, our best toaster oven for baking cookies guide can help you compare the oven itself rather than only its tray. Tray fit still matters, but even heat and rack position affect cookies just as much.
Finally, keep the old tray until the new one fits. A five minute check with the old part beside the replacement can save a return and a week without the oven.
How do dimensions affect fit?
Length and width determine whether the tray reaches the oven rails, while height affects rack clearance and door movement. Measure the old tray if you still have it, then measure the interior rails with the oven cool and unplugged.
The compact replacements cluster around 12.4 x 11 in. The GCQ tray is larger at 14.5 x 11.6 in, so it belongs with the TOA-95 and wide-oven choices rather than the smaller Cuisinart models.
Do not assume two trays fit because their names include the same oven family. Compare the stated dimensions and leave room for the door to close without pressure.
What material is best for a replacement tray?
The products here use metal or stainless steel. Stainless steel appears in the COWHERDING, GCQ and SettleDown options, while the Cuisinart TOA-60 part is listed as metal.
A stainless steel tray can suit buyers who want a solid replacement for baking, roasting or air frying. The finish and care instructions still matter, especially when a product has a nonstick finish or warns against abrasive cleaning tools.
Let the tray cool before washing. Soak stuck food instead of scraping it with metal tools, and dry the tray thoroughly when the care instructions call for hand washing.
How should you prepare a new stainless steel tray?
Follow the product's first-use instructions before cooking. COWHERDING recommends placing its tray or basket in a 300°F preheated oven for 10 minutes, and GCQ gives the same 300°F, 10-minute preheat guidance.
This one-time step is described as helping the steel adapt to high heat and reducing the chance of warping. Handle the tray only after it has cooled enough to move safely.
Use the temperature limit stated for the specific tray. The COWHERDING and GCQ products state heat resistance up to 480°F, but that limit does not automatically apply to every replacement part.
Verdict: which Cuisinart toaster oven tray replacement should you buy?
The COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement is the best all-around pick for TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 owners who want both a baking pan and basket. It gives you a solid pan for baking and drip catching, plus a mesh basket for air frying.
Choose the Cuisinart TOA-60 or TOA-70 crumb tray when exact model-specific replacement matters more than added cooking pieces. That is the simpler purchase when the lower tray is the only problem.
Pick the COWHERDING 2-tray set for batch baking. Two matching pans help when one is cooling, washing or ready for a second batch of cookies or roasted vegetables.
Pick the GCQ tray for a TOA-95 or compatible wide oven. Its larger 14.5 x 11.6 in surface belongs with wider ovens, not with the compact TOA-60 group.
Pick the SettleDown set for a TOA-060 or TOA-065 basket-and-tray replacement. Check its 1.3 in height and the mixed care guidance before you commit.
For every option, match the model number first. Then measure the oven rails, compare height and door clearance, and keep the old tray for a direct side by side check.
That short routine protects you from the most common mistake in this category. A tray can be well made and still be wrong for your cavity, while the right fit makes daily cooking easier from the first use.
Before ordering any Cuisinart toaster oven replacement tray, match the model number and measure the oven rails.
Our top 3 picks at a glance
-
1
Best for exact TOA-60 replacement
Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA-60 Convection Toaster
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for tray and basket versatility
COWHERDING Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
